Truth is, formations don't win matches on their own if the players lack the fight. Too often we look soft; the basics and a proper edge have to come back into the team.


Why the fight matters

Scottish football isn't a playground for fancy patterns — opposition sides come to make a name, to scrap, to get stuck in. If we let them set the tone then we're already on the back foot. That starts with attitude: intensity from the first whistle, concentration for 90 minutes and a readiness to put a foot in when needed. It's not about violence or overdoing it, it's about refusing to be bullied and making every challenge count.


Makhanya's case for leadership

Makhanya is the sort of player who almost forces you to notice him. He looks uncompromising, gets stuck in and then tries to drive play forward when teammates aren't offering the same urgency. Whether you agree with the style or not, you can see the example he sets — a visible determination that lifts the team, if others follow. That's what you want from a captain: someone who leads by action rather than words.


What needs to change on the pitch

The corrective is simple in concept but hard in practice. First, basics: crisp, simple passes at the right time, secure possession and better off-the-ball decisions. Second, a sharper mentality — close down quicker, win the initial duel, then move the ball. Third, leadership: a figure who sets standards, corrects errors on the pitch and injects that battle mentality when things go flat. You can debate formations forever, but without those elements we remain vulnerable.

To be fair, it's not rocket science. Managers, coaches and senior players all have parts to play. But fans see the pattern: a lack of bite, moments of sloppiness, and the odd player who looks ready to scrap. If the club wants to get back to being hard to beat and dominant in games, starting with mentality and leadership is the place to begin.

Written by Parlane! Parlane!: 30 October 2026