We all want players who look comfortable on the ball, but comfort doesn't always equal reliability. D. Neil and Fernandez show the technical attributes you'd hope for, yet both leave me uneasy for different reasons. It's early in the season, but those little moments keep piling up and they matter at this level.


D. Neil: plenty to like, but questions remain

On paper D. Neil ticks a lot of boxes — passing, reading the game, composure with the ball. The issue is physicality and, crucially, stamina when the team is forced onto the back foot. You can see the class in possession, but when the heat is on his execution can wobble. His mistake last night underlined that vulnerability. He’s certainly good enough to be in the squad, but being good isn’t the same as being the right fit for every game here.


Fernandez: talented but too casual at times

Fernandez frustrates me more than anyone. All the attributes are there: size, technique, a presence you’d expect to dominate. Yet he comes across as casual, taking extra touches at the wrong time and not showing the command you need from someone his stature. If you press him he can misread danger and tries to do too much in tight situations instead of clearing the ball or playing the simple option. Those repeated mistakes create uncertainty for the rest of the backline — something Rangers cannot afford on a regular basis.


What McInnes needs to consider now

I’d like to see Godfrey given a run and for Vanja to get some minutes, purely to test options and force competition. I back McInnes to find answers — but managers can be loyal and that sometimes delays change. Del will spot the problems; my hope is McInnes trusts his judgement and isn’t too slow to act. The truth is simple: you need defenders who are technically sound and who also cope when the pressure comes. Get that balance right and the nerves settle.

Written by Arcade_Penny: 18 October 2026