Something has shifted in the way we defend and it’s left players more exposed, plain and simple. A higher line and less direct midfield protection can make even a tidy centre-back look vulnerable, and that’s what I reckon we’ve been seeing.


What's changed at the back?

The shape feels different. We’re pushing up more and asking defenders to do more recovery work when the ball is played in behind. It can work if the midfield screens it out and the press stays compact, but when the timing or positioning is off the gaps open quickly. You can see why a player who once looked comfortable can suddenly struggle; football is about context as much as ability.


Raskin and the number 6 problem

I don’t think Raskin is a natural holding six in this setup. That role asks for discipline, constant orientation and the ability to act as a literal shield in front of the defence. If he needs constant instruction and to be moved around by the coach, then in a frantic spell, ten minutes after half-time when the crowd and the opposition are on top, that’s a tall order. We want players who recognise the danger and sort it out on the pitch, not wait for the touchline to intervene.


Tav's mobility and Sterling's role

Tav’s lack of recovery pace is something to take into account with a high line. It doesn’t mean he’s unusable, but it does mean someone has to cover the space he can’t get to. That used to be a midfield runner, the kind of role Ryan Jack gave us when we needed it. Sterling’s mobility gives him a natural advantage in that regard, so you can see why he might be the better option for keeping the balance when we’re pushed high.

Coaching and on-field leadership matter more in this setup. Managers can shout instructions, but players must read situations too. Someone has to organise the line, step to cover runs and call for a drop when the opponent is overloading an area. It’s not about constant intervention; it’s about building habits so the team recognises danger and adjusts instantly. If we see that stop-start of communication in big moments, the high line will keep costing us.

Overall, this isn’t about naming the weakest player. It’s about how the system exposes individuals. Get the shape and the midfield protection right and the same defenders look solid again. Leave holes and even good players find themselves on the back foot.

Written by Angus1812: 21 March 2026