Munn or McGuire — who’s the future No.1?

Reports have mentioned Pierce Charles, but you’re right to flag up the crop of keepers already around the club. We’ve got established faces and several youngsters coming through. The real question is which of those kids will step up and make the No.1 shirt their own in years to come.

Depth matters — not panic

To be fair, having Jack Butland and Liam Kelly occupying the top two spots gives Rangers breathing space. That’s important. It allows a measured approach to blooding younger keepers rather than throwing them to the wolves. You also mention loans — that pathway has been vital for goalies historically. Time away, game experience and handling pressure in competitive fixtures make a huge difference.

Munn v McGuire — what to look for

Neither name needs an overblown headline here, just a clear set of traits that suggest a future No.1. I’d be looking for command of the box, decision-making under pressure, distribution with feet and hands, and that stubborn belief when games go wrong. Reflexes are one thing; leadership and consistency are another. Which of Mason Munn or Rydnn McGuire ticks more of those boxes? That’s the real debate.

Patience, loans and timing

Young keepers often bloom later than outfielders. It’s normal. The sensible route is loan minutes first, then a gradual handover if they’re ready. You can see why reports about other keepers will surface — clubs always look for competition — but Rangers look well covered for now. Ultimately the one who owns the No.1 jersey will be the keeper who combines technique with temperament and seizes the chance when it arrives.

So I’d say keep watching both Munn and McGuire, follow their game time and how they cope in senior matches. No crystal ball needed — form, minutes and composure will tell the story. What do others reckon? Who’s your money on?

Written by Sir Walter Smith OBE: 28 May 2026