I've always loved watching Rangers when we've had proper wingers — the kind who change a game with a burst of pace or a bit of imagination. Barrie McKay was one of those youngsters who, at his best, felt like he belonged in that line. Seeing him recently sign a short-term deal with Hamilton Accies made me wonder again: did he ever reach what everyone expected of him?
What the lad had
When McKay came through he looked a genuine talent. Explosive over short distances, tidy on the ball and comfortable taking players on, he had that natural flair you rarely teach. I remember Davie Weir, back in the Warburton days, praising his ability — I wasn’t alone in thinking he could go on to bigger things. For a while he was a bright spot, the sort of player who could turn a tight game with a single run or a clever flick.
Why it never quite clicked
Truth is, football is littered with players who have all the tools but never quite put it together consistently. With McKay it always felt like flashes rather than a steady climb. Whether it was lack of game time, the right move at the right time, or just moments that didn’t turn into opportunities, something didn’t line up. That’s not to be harsh — it happens. Players develop at different rates and sometimes the circumstances never match the ability.
Where that leaves him and us
He’s still only 31 and carving out a career, now at Hamilton, and fans will always have that sense of what might have been. I’ll always remember the glimpses of brilliance — the pace, the trickery, the confidence on the ball. How highly did I rate him? High for potential, a bit more cautious for the way his career actually went. Are we disappointed? Yes, but there's still respect for the talent and a reminder that the winger tradition at Rangers gives you those memorable moments, even if they don’t always become a long, glittering career.
So, fellow bears, how did you see him back then? Overrated, unlucky, or just one of those players who never quite caught the breaks?
Related Articles
About Rangers News Views
Rangers News Views offers daily Glasgow Rangers coverage including match reaction, transfer analysis, SPFL context, tactical breakdowns and opinion-led articles written by supporters for supporters.