A change of manager may not, on its own, solve Scotland’s deeper problem: the country does not seem to produce players of the quality it once did. It is a bleak argument, but it is hard not to look back at the names who came through from the 1970s into the early 1990s and wonder what has changed.
A remarkable generation, and a difficult comparison
Scotland had players making their mark across English football, at clubs including Leeds United, Liverpool and Manchester United. Dalglish, Souness, Hansen, Bremner, Gray, Lorimer, Jordan, Martin Buchan, Crerand and McQueen are just some of the names that spring to mind. Asa Hartford and Willie Johnston are reminders that there was quality beyond those headline examples, too.
That is a daunting roll-call to compare with the present day. It can make the current pool feel thin, especially when you start asking who is coming through to replace established internationals. But nostalgia can blur the picture as well. We remember the great players, while the ordinary ones from every generation tend to fade from view.
It is not only about the manager
There is a case for asking whether coaching and development were better in that earlier period. Scotland qualified for three successive World Cups, from 1974 to 1982, and the country produced players who could thrive at a high level. That does not, by itself, tell us exactly why. The reasons behind a shift in player development are bigger than any single coach or tactical system.
Stevie Clarke is a useful reference point in one respect. I never took to his cautious style, and it could be hard to watch, but he did guide Scotland to the European Championship finals. That is an important achievement, even if it does not settle the wider question of how Scotland develops more top-class footballers.
Where does the next group come from?
Pocognoli would be taking a risk, in this view, if he believes open, expansive football can work without the players to carry it out. A team needs quality on the ball, but also the legs and awareness to press, recover its shape and cope with transitions. Tactics can help a group, certainly, but they cannot conjure a whole generation of elite players from nowhere.
And the concern is what happens as the current senior names move on. McGinn, McTominay, Robertson and Tierney are the sort of players whose absence would leave a serious gap. It is fair to ask who is ready to step into those roles, rather than simply hoping the next manager finds a solution.
I do not have a neat answer for why Scotland’s supply of top players seems to have fallen away. Nor does one comparison with the past explain everything. But the question deserves more than a change of formation or a new face in the dugout. The fear is that, without better players coming through, Scotland could slip well below the level supporters expect. That is a gloomy thought, admittedly. Still, it is difficult to wave away.
Related Articles
About Rangers News Views
Rangers News Views offers daily Glasgow Rangers coverage including match reaction, transfer analysis, SPFL context, tactical breakdowns and opinion-led articles written by supporters for supporters.