Short version: you can't treat Manchester City and Rangers as equivalent cases. The accusations, the corporate consequences and the rules governing each situation are in different universes, and that matters.
Nature of the allegations
To be fair, on the surface both stories involve financial wrongdoing. But dig a bit and the differences are obvious. One set of claims focuses on alleged manipulation of accounting, sponsorship and reporting across a lengthy period under Premier League rules. The other concerns the use of EBT-style payments under previous ownership and the way that led to insolvency. They sit in different categories — one is about alleged regulatory concealment, the other about payments, tax treatment and the collapse of a company.
Operational fallout
Here's where the comparison really falls apart. City’s corporate structure, for all the debate, remains a functioning, well-resourced football business contesting sanctions through the appropriate legal channels. Rangers, as most of us know painfully well, went through a period where the original company could not continue as a going concern and entered liquidation, forcing football to be rebuilt from the bottom tiers. Those outcomes are fundamentally different and shape how each case is handled.
Different rules, different forums
Remember the rulebook changes everything. Premier League and English disciplinary processes operate differently to SFA and Scottish licensing regimes. That affects evidence, penalties and the practical remedies available. You can see why legal experts and people inside both clubs stress the distinctions — comparing them glosses over serious structural and regulatory variation.
Look, as a Rangers fan I'm not trying to be defensively clever — the point is simple. Equating the two is lazy. The nature of the alleged deception, the corporate consequences and the governing frameworks are not the same, and anyone arguing otherwise needs to explain which bit they actually mean.
Related Articles
About Rangers News Views
Rangers News Views offers daily Glasgow Rangers coverage including match reaction, transfer analysis, SPFL context, tactical breakdowns and opinion-led articles written by supporters for supporters.