On the surface the early results under Martin and McInnes looked similar. The big difference wasn’t tactics on a whiteboard — it was what they did when no one else was looking.


The McInnes way

McInnes made the shirt matter from day one. He didn’t duck criticism; he used it to galvanise the group. You can see why players would run the extra mile for a manager who shares the pain and refuses to let anyone hide from it. The image of diverting the plane back from Czech to Aberdeen and then living out the consequences with the squad in a hotel is stark, but it says something important: he was sharing responsibility, not pointing fingers.

That builds a siege mentality in the best sense — a team that looks after each other, that defends the manager as much as the manager defends them. From misfits to fighters, that transformation is more about trust and commitment than a new shape on the pitch.


Martin’s pressure cooker

By contrast, Martin seemed to create an environment where players felt talked at rather than backed. Protection turned into intense scrutiny. Suddenly the natural instinct — to take risks, to play with the ball and express yourself — was replaced by fear of being singled out for tactical errors.

When you coach people into avoiding mistakes, they stop playing to win. They freeze. Moments that require instincts become hesitant. The end result is grinding, low-confidence performances where the structure collapses because no one will commit to anything for fear of blame.


Why culture matters

Managers can have similar ideas on the training ground, but it’s how they carry those ideas into the locker room that decides whether they stick. Accountability without protection becomes anxiety; leadership without solidarity becomes isolation. That’s the gulf between the two spells.

So while results give the headlines, culture decides the long game. Enjoy the international break — and remember, Glasgow is blue.

Written by EHL2020: 24 September 2026