To be fair, it feels a bit harsh to call the recent additions failures after only a short time. Barron in particular hasn't exactly flopped when given a run; he became a full international, his value has risen and, even if he's quiet just now, he's a useful squad option with resale potential. That's not the sort of deal you call a blunder.


Barron — steady, not spectacular

Truth is, not every signing needs to be a headline-grabber. Some players are there to do a job when called upon, keep the standards high in training and be reliable cover. That's where Barron fits. He isn't lighting up every week, but he has earned international recognition and, crucially, hasn't let the club down for what we paid. You can see why supporters would expect immediate fireworks, but steady contribution and potential to sell on at a profit counts for something.


McCrorie and Shankland — too early to bury them

We're talking about lads who've barely had time to settle. Shankland was beginning to look like a smart piece of business before circumstances interrupted that momentum; if he returns as backup to two in-form forwards, that doesn't erase the value of the deal. McCrorie was never going to be a miracle winger or a full-blooded Cafu — that's unrealistic. What he offers is versatility. Cover across three or four positions is gold for any manager when injuries and fixture pile-up arrive.


Why the training ground matters

Don't forget, success isn't only judged on matchdays. Players who bring a good vibe, push the regulars and keep standards up in training help the whole squad. Devlin has that old-school SPL stalwart feel about him and there have been positive noises about what these guys add behind the scenes. So yeah, be critical if you must — but maybe wait until May before writing anyone off entirely. Give them time to show it on the pitch and in the dressing room.

Written by Mysister4Zungu: 7 November 2026