To be fair, there are valid worries about the way things have gone recently. You can see why folk get frustrated when we're behind Celtic and struggling in Europe. But that frustration shouldn't turn sensible debate into doom-mongering that treats possibility as fact.


Being ahead doesn't mean everything else is wrong

Yes, Celtic look to be in a healthier place right now, especially in European terms. That simply means they're ahead of us at the moment. It doesn't automatically prove our strategy is fundamentally flawed or that the club's only aim is to flip players for cash. Those are different claims. The sensible approach is to recognise a gap, work out why it exists and fix it, not invent a grand conspiracy.


Recruitment and manager changes — context matters

Labelling the last few years an 'absolute shambles' because of numerous signings and managerial changes is a bit too neat. New ownership inherited a club with problems; change sometimes brings turnover. That doesn't prove there's no plan. If anything, the push towards signing younger players and building a sustainable recruitment model suggests a different long-term aim rather than simply chucking money at a quick fix.


Young players can win things — and grow value

There's a common mistaken idea that buying youth equals prioritising profit over trophies. It isn't mutually exclusive. A young player can slot in, help win silverware and later have resale value. The ideal is obvious: bring in players who improve the team now and grow in value later. Criticism should focus on whether that process is actually delivering, not on a blanket indictment of the approach.

In short, calling the club visionless or saying season-ticket holders will evaporate is speculation dressed up as certainty. Critique is welcome — constructive critique that points out where recruitment has failed, where the squad needs strengthening and what should change. But predicting the worst and treating it as fact does nobody any favours. Keep the bar high, but let's keep the arguments honest.

Written by Angus1812: 28 August 2026