To be fair, the picture around Neil has been muddied by people assuming too much. Raskin's upturn in form has, surprisingly, come with Neil alongside him too. So that argument can work both ways. A lot of the noise comes from reading substitutions and selections as hard evidence of a player being poor. It isn't always like that.


Don't read too much into a sub

Think about it: managers use subs for rhythm, match-up problems, fitness and game management as much as punishment. McInnes might take a player off to change shape, to protect a lead, or to give someone a breather. If he follows that up by starting the same player in the next game, it tells you more about a plan than a knee-jerk judgement. In Neil's case the pattern hasn’t been 'taken off, frozen out', it has looked like careful handling while the gaffer tried to find a settled XI. That matters. Fans want clear signals, but the manager gets the wider view every day in training.


Consistency is the cure

Consistency on the pitch breeds confidence. Since McInnes has given Neil a run of starts, and the claim he's been Man of the Match in four straight starts is being made by other supporters, you can see why belief grows. Players respond to regular minutes, familiar partnerships and clarity over their role. Thelwell or Raskin linking up better with him runs both ways; confidence can be contagious. We shouldn't pretend form appears in isolation. There's a rhythm to the team, patterns of play, pressing and transitions, and having players know exactly what's expected helps them express themselves. If the manager wants Neil central to a plan, then starting him consistently makes perfect sense even if there were earlier doubts.


Keep perspective

We need to be honest: supporters will always debate selections. It's part of being a fan. But the reasonable take is to judge by what the manager has actually done over weeks, not by single substitutions. McInnes's job is to balance short-term result with long-term cohesion, and giving a player consistency to find form is a recognised approach. So rather than assume Neil was dropped because he wasn't good enough, look at the pattern. He's started the last four and people are noticing the difference. That's the story here. Let's let the player keep playing, keep improving, and see how it pans out without inventing narratives from one change.

Written by Angus1812: 21 September 2026