There’s a fair bit of heat around McInnes right now and you can see why. The argument goes: his recent run owed as much to circumstance as coaching, and his career so far doesn’t scream ‘Rangers manager’. That’s the blunt summary, and it’s one worth taking seriously.


Was last season just luck?

To be fair, context matters. After the January window last season Hearts dipped and, for long stretches, both we and Celtic were far from our best. That mix left gaps in the table that a sensible, organised team could exploit. You can’t say that had no influence on outcomes. Saying a manager benefited from circumstances isn’t the same as saying he did nothing, but you can see why supporters question how much of the success was coaching and how much was simply being in the right place at the right time.


What his record actually looks like

People point out that across a long career McInnes hasn’t collected a stack of silverware. The claim here is one cup and one promotion in around fifteen years, and that paints a picture more of steady competence than of someone who elevates clubs repeatedly. He’s often taken sides to where you’d expect them to finish rather than vaulting them past definitively stronger opponents. That’s a fair critique if your yardstick is managerial greatness rather than solid stewardship.


Style, fit and the bigger picture

There’s also the question of fit. Folks have argued he wouldn’t pair well with an analytical recruitment model that wants tight alignment between data and playing profile. If a manager wants heavy say over signings and a particular type of player, that can clash with an ownership model. Rangers aren’t looking just to survive; the aim is to close gaps. So even if McInnes is tidy and organised, is that the ambition we need? That’s the real bone of contention.

Ultimately, calling him ‘average’ might sting, but it’s a view rooted in reasonable points: modest trophy haul, results that often match expectations rather than defy them, and potential mismatch with certain club models. Fans can disagree, but these are the questions any supporter should want answered before dreaming big.

Written by Gers78!!: 5 September 2026