Roberto Martínez’s record with Belgium and Portugal is impressive, but comparing him with the managers before him makes it difficult to credit the coach alone. The figures point to a bigger truth in international football: a deep, gifted generation can keep a country operating at a high level through a change in the dugout. That does not make the manager irrelevant. It does put his contribution in perspective.
Belgium had a remarkable base to work from
The Belgium comparison is striking. Marc Wilmots had a 67.4% win rate and took the side to No. 1 in the FIFA ranking. Martínez then kept Belgium at No. 1, with a 70.0% win rate. Different coaches, broadly similar outcomes at the top end. Belgium’s Golden Generation, including De Bruyne, Hazard and Lukaku, gave both managers an exceptional base to work from.
Belgium remained a major force and reached the latter stages of major tournaments, but did not turn that consistency into a trophy. That matters when judging the period. The talent was there, and the results stayed strong, yet the ultimate prize remained out of reach. It is fair to say Martínez did well; it is also fair to recognise that the quality of the squad gave him a considerable platform.
Portugal tells a similar story
There is a comparable pattern with Portugal. Fernando Santos recorded a 61.5% win rate, while Martínez’s figure is 66.7%. Both delivered consistency and silverware. Portugal stayed in the FIFA top five under each, peaking at third with Santos and fifth with Martínez, and won the Nations League in 2019 and 2025 respectively.
Those figures make it hard to argue that a change of manager transformed the country’s standing. Martínez’s record is strong, but Santos had already set a high standard. The team’s continued success across the change points towards the depth and quality available to Portugal, not just a different voice on the training pitch.
Good management is not the whole explanation
International football is a different job from club management. A coach has to work with the players a country produces, and the strength of that group shapes what is possible. There is less room to build a squad from scratch, so a golden generation can sustain a high level across different managers. That is the useful point here, rather than a claim that tactics or coaching do not matter.
Win rates and rankings cannot tell the whole story on their own, either. They do not explain every choice, performance or tournament outcome. But when the broad results remain comparable under successive managers, it is reasonable to look beyond the dugout for part of the explanation.
So this is not an argument that Martínez is a poor manager. His records with both countries are plainly strong. It is simply a reminder that he inherited talented groups and that his predecessors had also achieved a high level of success. The manager deserves credit, but not all the credit. In these cases, the players were a huge part of the story.
Related Articles
About Rangers News Views
Rangers News Views offers daily Glasgow Rangers coverage including match reaction, transfer analysis, SPFL context, tactical breakdowns and opinion-led articles written by supporters for supporters.