We can't have it both ways. One minute Kevin Thomson — who was in the commentary box — says the side were controlling spells of the match, and the next some folks online write off the whole squad as a hopeless mess.


Pick a lane: criticism or caricature?

Look, criticism is healthy. Point out the weak bits and demand improvements. But painting every player as useless while also claiming the squad is just three signings away is contradictory. Either the structure and shape are there and we can tweak, or the whole thing needs ripping up. You can’t credibly argue both depending on which sequence of play you dislike.


There are genuine positives — don’t ignore them

To be fair, admitting the team has flaws doesn’t mean pretending everything is fine. If Gassama had a decent outing, if Naderi brings something different down his flank, and if the team actually controlled periods, those are real takeaways. Small things matter — off the ball shape, a tidy spell of possession, a midfield who can link play. Those moments give you a base to improve from.


Focus on measured analysis, not hyperbole

We can, and should, demand reinforcements in areas that are clearly weak. But the doom-laden line that 'any decent team will destroy us' is hyperbole and doesn’t help anyone. Tactical questions — tempo, pressing, transition — deserve calm heads and specific suggestions, not blanket insults. Truth is, honest appraisal recognises both the positives and the faults. That’s how progress happens.

In short: argue hard, but argue smart. There’s work to do, yes. There’s also a platform to build on, yes. Treating both realities as mutually exclusive won’t make the club any better.

Written by Angus1812: 28 August 2026