We can agree on one basic point straight away: EBTs as a concept were not an outlawed scheme when clubs and companies used them. The row wasn’t about the idea itself. It was about how Rangers applied it and whether that application stood up to scrutiny. The Supreme Court answer in 2017 made that clear.


Avoidance versus evasion — the important difference

To be fair, people throw those two words around as if they’re interchangeable. They are not. Tax avoidance is arranging affairs within the law to reduce tax. Tax evasion is deliberately hiding or misrepresenting information to avoid tax. That difference matters, legally and morally. The dispute around our EBTs centred on whether the arrangements actually did what we thought they did.


How the EBTs were presented

Between 2001 and 2010 Rangers used EBT structures. Plenty of firms across the UK employed similar trusts, often backed by professional advice. The common line was that money paid into trusts and then advanced as loans to employees didn’t count as taxable earnings. It sounded plausible at the time, and a lot of people accepted it.


Why it collapsed in court

The truth is in the legal detail. After lengthy litigation the UK Supreme Court concluded the way Rangers used the trusts didn’t achieve the tax result the club claimed. The Court sided with HMRC, saying those payments were effectively remuneration and should have fallen under PAYE and National Insurance. That distinction — between a theoretically acceptable structure and its practical application — is the heart of the matter.

Finally, just because other organisations and clubs used EBTs doesn’t mean everyone used them the same way. That’s no defence if a particular application fails under legal examination.

Written by EHL2020: 30 September 2026