There’s always a chorus calling for Derek to go and I get the anger. Folks want a manager who wins, is tactically clever and improves players. The trouble is, that brief sounds simple until you try to hire someone who actually fits it and will come to Ibrox.


The impossible brief

Look at the names thrown about: Gio, Beale, Clement, Rohl, even Eddie Howe gets mentioned. Each of those ticks some boxes but none are perfect fits for everything fans demand. Some are excellent at improving individuals. Some are good tactically. Few combine both with a proven winning mentality in this environment.

And that’s the rub. It’s easy to say “get someone better” from the terraces. It’s another thing to recruit a coach who will accept the pressures, the scrutiny and the transfer constraints that come with managing Rangers. So the calls for sacking feel clean and satisfying, but what’s the realistic alternative?


Recruitment is where this falls down

Honestly, I think the bigger problem isn’t always the man in the dugout. It’s who’s signing the players and how they’re scouted. The head coach should have input, of course, but when signings are driven by committees and spreadsheets you can end up with a squad that doesn’t suit the coach’s shape or tempo.

If a manager has his own trusted coach, his own scouting network and his own list of targets, then blame is clearer when it goes wrong. Right now responsibility looks muddled — and that breeds impatience. Fans see poor recruitment and blame the manager first, but there’s a whole system behind it.


What might actually work

So what do we want? A tactician who develops players and wins. Great. But more realistically we need someone who can work with a clearer recruitment model, given the club’s constraints. An old-school first-team coach with control over recruitment and a coherent backroom setup would be a start.

Short-term sackings feel cathartic. Long-term fixes need structure. You can’t keep swapping coaches and expect the problem to magically disappear if the scouting and recruitment remain broken. That’s where the board — and whoever’s pulling the strings on transfers — need to be honest with supporters.

To be fair, I don’t have the perfect name. Few do. But until recruitment and decision-making lines are straightened out, changing the manager might just be rearranging deckchairs.

Written by Superally92: 31 August 2026