We need to buy the best talent we can afford, yes. But more important is signing players who can adapt quickly to the unique demands of the club and who bring the right mentality. That doesn’t happen overnight. You either build a core who know what being at this club means, or you try to fast-track it with a handful of wise heads to steady the ship.


Why an experienced core matters

There’s a difference between buying a good player and buying somebody who helps the group. Experienced pros set standards. They show the newcomers how we press, how we defend the wide areas, how we cope with the pressure of the Old Firm and the expectations at Ibrox. To be fair, teams who have a clear identity and a spine of seasoned players make integration so much easier for anyone coming in.

You mentioned Mccrorie and Shankalnd. That’s the idea – a few players who have seen it, who can point the new lads in the right direction. McGregor at the core of it, even players like Maeda in specific roles, can contribute in ways that don’t show up in a headline stat. Leadership isn’t always loud. Sometimes it’s the quiet bit of learning on the training ground and at meals that matters.


Not about nationality, but about fit

This isn’t a plea to only buy Scottish. Far from it. It’s about buying quality with the right mental attitude. If a player knows what the club expects, or is coached into it, he’ll adapt. If he doesn’t, no amount of talent will be enough. Celtic have seemed to nail that balance for longer than us. We need to learn the lesson: identity and mentality trump tokens or box-ticking.


Practical steps: coaches, ex-players and culture

One practical move is to involve ex-players in coaching and mentoring roles. They understand the club’s habits and can pass them on. We’ve often missed that. Recruitment should look for character as well as technique, and the club must be set up to bring new signings into the culture quickly.

In short: buy quality, but buy players who can live the job day-to-day. Build a core that teaches the rest. It’s not glamorous, but it’s how you make signings stick.

Written by Angus1812: 10 July 2026