I rate Fernandez as a talented centre half, but he can give you the fear when he takes unnecessary chances, acting as if something is too easy. His ability isn't the issue, temperament sometimes is. That's worrying because a defender needs to be solid more often than flashy.


Fernandez's ups and downs

To be fair, there are moments when he looks like the real thing, dominant in the air, comfortable stepping out, and quick to read certain situations. But then you'll see him gamble on a tackle or a risky pass and suddenly you're holding your breath. It's not that he's a liability every week, more that the risky moments stick out. You want your centre half to frustrate the opposition, not provide them chances through misjudgement.

Honestly, the fix is obvious, more measured decisions in key moments. If Fernandez pares back the risky bits and chooses safety when required, he becomes a pillar. He's shown he can dominate but needs to make that the default rather than the exception. The talent is there; it just needs to be steady.


Makhanya and Naderi growing into their roles

Makhanya, by contrast, is a calming presence. He's smooth on the ball, composed in defence and pleasing to watch. When he's in command I feel more relaxed, simple as that. He doesn't overcomplicate things and his ball control and tempo help the team settle.

As for Naderi, I admit I was sceptical before, but the big fella is growing on me. His work-rate was never the concern, he always covers ground, but he had to learn to add end product to those runs. He's started doing that. His goal yesterday was a striker's finish: in the right place, timely run and the simple tap-in when the chance came. That sort of positional sense is encouraging.

The tap-in from Penrice showed the sort of simple finishing we hope to see more of. Naderi's willingness to get into the box and finish is a welcome development; it takes defenders out of position and opens lanes for others.


Bouanani the standout

Truth is, Bouanani looked a cut above against Aberdeen. Whether he drew one, two or three defenders, he still found space and caused problems. You could see class in his movement and decision-making; the opposition struggled to contain him. Moments like that remind you why we get excited about certain players.

Overall, it's a mixed bag. Fernandez needs a bit more consistency; Makhanya gives confidence; Naderi is adding the bits he was missing. Small improvements in temperament and end product could make a big difference.

Written by Sir Walter Smith OBE: 1 November 2026