There is a nervousness among supporters after Rohl moved on and McInnes took the job. He comes with a track record that includes one League Cup and a couple of second-tier titles, plus that well-publicised near miss with Hearts and a Rangers connection. Those facts make him a credible appointment, but the early picture has left plenty of fans uneasy.


Where the doubts come from

People are asking sensible questions. His biggest signing was reportedly £2m and some of his backroom staff have mainly worked at lower levels. That can look worrying when results and performances are sluggish. Add in the chatter that he talks a good game but hasn’t yet shown it on the pitch, and you can see why some are calling for action. It is not unreasonable to wonder whether he’s out of his depth at a club with Rangers’ expectations.


Why patience might be the smarter call

On the other hand, knee-jerk sackings have hurt this club before. If we move for the exit door now we only reinforce that reputation. McInnes came in with his own ideas and staff. He needs time to bed in, assess the squad properly and stamp a style on the team. By giving him the season we give him the chance to show progress, or lack of it, over a reasonable period. We will also see what the squad looks like once the transfer window settles and whether he can shape it to his gameplan.


What to expect and when to worry

Realistically, the next few weeks will clarify a lot. We’ll learn what players are available and how the team looks in domestic fixtures. If there’s genuine, sustained decline then action is justified. If there’s gradual improvement or a clear plan emerging, patience will look smart. This is a big opportunity for McInnes to prove he can handle the job. If he can’t, then other names will inevitably be mentioned, but let’s not hand in our verdict before he’s had the tools and time to try.

To be fair, supporters are right to be opinionated. I’m uneasy too. But rushing to sack now feels like a step we’ll regret more often than not. Give the season, see the picture, then decide.

Written by BearAbroad22: 31 August 2026