Is It Time For Tav To Move On?

There’s a straightforward question doing the rounds: should James Tavernier move on? You can see both sides. He’s made mistakes, and fans want more silverware, but that doesn’t erase a decade of sheer value from a player who’s given the club a lot to be grateful for.

The complaints are fair

To be honest, some of the criticism isn’t wild. Over ten years a full back will be involved in moments that cost the team, and supporters are right to expect more trophies when you’ve had sustained spells of dominance at club level. If you feel Tavernier has cost us goals or games at times, you’re not alone — plenty of fans have pointed that out and won’t let it lie.

But don’t forget what he gave us

That said, you can’t shrug off what he’s delivered either. For 250k to come in and provide roughly 300 goal contributions from full back is remarkable by any measure. He was a key figure in that unforgettable run to a European final and chipped in with goals and leadership season after season. He rarely missed games, carried himself with class, and picked up a couple of cups along the way. Those are the moments people remember — and rightly so.

Where the blame really lies

Calling him a serial loser feels lazy. The club has had structural problems since 2012 and failures to win more trophies are down to many factors and many people, not just one player. Football is a team game and a club game; you can criticise Tavernier’s errors without making him the only scapegoat for wider failings.

So yes, maybe his best days are winding down and maybe a fresh start suits everyone at some point. But when he goes, let’s remember the positives as well as the negatives. He’s been, by and large, a bargain signing who gave his all. If he walks away, he should get our thanks and best wishes — fans can be tough, but fair.

Written by Jackboy55: 15 June 2026