This isn't a take about loyalty or not. It's about whether McInnes is the right man for the way Rangers seem to be operating now. If the club are recruiting players for particular traits and future value rather than to slot straight into a single rigid system, you need a coach who can bend, adapt and build a coherent identity around those characteristics.


Recruitment has changed — why that matters

Clubs across Europe and in the Premier League are buying smarter: they identify attributes, potential and upside. There's nothing wrong with that. It can be very successful if done properly. But it does change what you need on the touchline. You don't necessarily buy eleven players who all fit one pre-set pattern; you assemble a squad with varied strengths and expect the coach to find the best way to use them together.


Where McInnes looks out of step

The problem, as the original poster put it, is McInnes feels like an old-school manager who wants to control the system and bring players who fit his idea. He virtually said it last night. That rigidity shows in constant tactical tinkering, set-up changes and regular half-time subs — signs he may be trying to force players into shapes they're not comfortable with. If the players are bought for their individual qualities, they need someone who can combine those traits into a functioning team, not someone who demands they all change to suit him.


What we'd actually benefit from

Rangers need an intelligent, flexible coach who can pick a pragmatic style based on the players at hand, keep it consistent, and work on the weaknesses. Someone who can mould differing profiles into a coherent unit, rather than insist on a single template. That's not a criticism of buying for value — it's just realistic about what that approach asks of the manager. Right now I don't see McInnes as the ideal fit for that specific brief.

Written by Gers78!!: 5 September 2026