I’ll keep saying it: this isn’t a defence so much as a reminder of context. Purdy only joined last June and Thelwell in October. If recruitment has been failing for several years, it’s unfair to point the finger at two recent arrivals and call it a day.


What do people mean by "football people"?

When Souness talked about needing "football people" involved in recruitment, the point seemed to be that you shouldn’t rely on stats alone. Fair enough. But some fans treat that phrase as shorthand for ex-pros who played at the top level. Problem is, plenty of successful recruiters and execs never had long professional playing careers. Koppen didn’t play top-level football, Arsenal’s recruitment setup isn’t full of household-name ex-players, and two of Man City’s senior recruitment figures didn’t play professionally either. Even the scout linked to finding Erling Haaland wasn’t a Bundesliga star — that doesn’t make his eye for talent worthless.


Data versus the eye test — it’s not binary

The modern model is a marriage of numbers and people watching football. Data flags patterns, scouts provide the eye test and context, and technical staff judge fit for the squad. To be fair, Purdy’s remit has had a technical aspect and both he and Thelwell have scouting backgrounds. So if recruitment has been off the mark, it’s sensible to look beyond just the directors: are the scouts doing their jobs? Is the brief clear? Is the process joined up? Blaming the execs alone skips half the picture.


Give it a bit of time

We can and should debate who’s responsible, but knee-jerk reactions after seven games or so are driven by emotion. Souness operated in a different era when big-money buys could be made; his scouting hits and misses show the eye test isn’t foolproof either. My view is simple: don’t write off people after a short run. Give the recruitment structure a chance to bed in, look properly at the scouting work, and judge on evidence — not just on frustration from a poor run of results.

Written by Angus1812: 7 September 2026