To be fair, nobody is making life easy for McInnes right now. Pick one approach and it’s criticised; pick another and it’s criticised as well. After last night — that was the worst I’ve seen from us for a while — the anger is understandable. But the sore point isn’t just tactics. It’s a squad stretched thin, with several players clearly unsettled and not ready to step in and change things.


Why criticism feels relentless

Fans are quick to judge and that’s fair. When results go wrong a manager will always get heat. But there’s a difference between being judged on a clear plan that fails and being blamed for constant tinkering. The problem is consistency. You can see why people get frustrated when changes half-time and formations shift about. Yet when substitutions are made it’s often because the manager can see players are off the pace or off the attitude — you can’t ignore that.


Squad issues are the real worry

Talk of eight players waiting for moves says it all. If you’ve got a chunk of the squad unsettled, the blend and the workrate disappear. It’s not just a lack of talent, it’s availability and willingness. I’ve managed teams in my life and the truth is: if someone doesn’t want to give you 100 per cent, coaching can only do so much. A player who’s already looking elsewhere won’t necessarily respond the same way as someone fighting for their place.


What can be done?

Realistically, there are no instant fixes. Fans want boldness, a clear identity and better bodies on the pitch. That means recruitment and getting the unsettled players sorted either way. In the meantime, the manager is forced into reactive moves — half-time subs, formation changes — because he’s trying to salvage results with what’s available. I have sympathy for McInnes on that front, even if we all want better on the pitch.

We can be ruthless in our assessments, and rightly so after poor displays. Just don’t forget the context: depth, attitude and a busy window of departures make any manager’s job harder. The board and recruitment need to back the manager properly, and the players who remain must show the basics: effort, shape and respect for the jersey.

Written by Angus1812: 6 September 2026